Come see us at a show!!

Or give us a call at (618) 698-3748

Or email

Mail-In / Shipping Information

Please ship your items using delivery confirmation/tracking to ensure delivery and send us an email so we can look for your package. We cannot be responsible for lost or damaged packages.

Send your items to:

After the Game
804 Charlotte Ave
Columbia, IL. 62236

We charge the following for return shipping on mail-in items:

  • Standard Shipping (Photos, balls, etc) is $8.
  • Oversized shipping is $12 or more.
  • Large and heavy items will require extra shipping and confirmation.

Signers reserve the right to refuse any item or inscription.

With your mail-in items, please send a copy of your online purchase receipt (emailed to you with details of the items purchased; order number, player, quantity, etc.) or our mail-in order form with payment in full.

After the Game, Inc is a family owned sports promotion company and retailer with over 30 years experience in the industry.  Not only are we an internet based sports memorabilia business, we also promote an annual three day sports show with autograph guests and vendors each October in St. Louis, Mo. We also exhibit at shows across the United States each year and offer private signings with athletes and celebrities.

We specialize in Hall of Fame and superstar autographs especially those of St. Louis and Chicago athletes including baseballs, photos, rookie cards and much more. We also carry an extensive inventory across all sports, along with celebrities, historical and political autographs. Most items are authenticated by PSA, JSA, or Beckett obtained at one of our signings. In addition, we have both individual sports cards and complete sets with many PSA or Beckett graded cards. We are always looking to purchase your collections or card.

Admission info
item types (cards, regular, oversized, etc)
COA info (Beckett, JSA, etc) at shows

Shopping Cart